Review: Fly By Night

flybynight-316x480Title:  Fly By Night

Author:  Frances Hardinge

Publisher:  Macmillan Publishers, 2005 (UK)

HarperCollins, 2006 (US)

Genre:  Fantasy

Awards: Branford Boase Award (UK), School Library Journal’s Best Books of 2006 (US)

 

I was excited to find this book on display at my local library during the American Library Association’s “Banned Books Week” back in October. I picked it up, read half of it, lost interest, then recently checked it out again to give it another shot. I know what you’re thinking, “You lost interest in an award-winning Fantasy book which is about banned books?!” Unfortunately, the answer is yes.  Although Fly By Night is an adventure story filled with unique and quirky characters and a world that is unlike our own, overall, I found the book to be tedious.

The book is written in faux old English, at an unnamed time and place which mildly resembles jolly old England at the turn of the century. The writing has some amusing attributes – my favorite being that each chapter is lettered and titled, “A is for…”, “B is for…” and so on – but many of the chapter are simply too long and contain too many side stories which do not serve the plot whatsoever.

Mosca, our main character, is a Spunky young girl whose deceased father was once a great writer. Because of this Mosca has learned to read and write,  which in a world where written word is not only banned but feared, leads her to become intertwined in a full on war. Mosca meets a con man who is involved with several guilds which resemble social / religious / political groups. The guild leaders among the only characters who can read and write. They use the power of fear to manipulate the general public into following their guild – eventually this leads to a full on war. Mosca, who cannot seem to stay out of trouble becomes a key player in the outcome of the battle. The book ends with an uncertainty for where Mosca, her con man, and the general public will end up next.

Though this book has many great attributes of a riveting fantasy novel, the length, word choice, and never-ending subplots prevent me from recommending it to any of my friends. If wordiness and meandering plots is your thing, I’d find this book suitable for readers aged 10+.

 

Posted by: Janine Reads

Advertisements

5 Comments

Filed under Uncategorized

5 responses to “Review: Fly By Night

  1. Fred Reads

    Mosca sounds like a renegade and there seems to be a lot of tariff in this book. (Disclaimer: The following comments include nerdy words such as “tariff” and “alliteration”. These are words from my spelling tests, and my assignment is to use them in comments. You, therefore, cannot poke fun at me for using such words.) Is there a sequel to this book? If so, that may explain why it comes to such a seemingly sudden ending. You may not want to read it if the material itself is bad, but The Breadwinner had an end similar to what your describing, and it matched with the beginning of Parvana’s Journey.

  2. Fred Reads

    I’m hoping to get out with my telescope soon. I hope I see the nebula in Orion’s belt. Jupiter’s supposed to be really close to the moon, too.

  3. Fred Reads

    P.S. I’m NOT commemorating these words to my heritage of nerdyness. Just hope I don’t geek out and start talking about the physics of three-dimensional polygons. Oh, I just learned a cool fact about vaccines. Did you know that the first vaccine came from cow pox?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s